The Legacy of Methodological Dualism
نویسندگان
چکیده
Methodological dualism in linguistics occurs when its theories are subjected to standards that are inappropriate for them qua scientifi c theories. Despite much opposition, methodological dualism abounds in contemporary thinking. In this paper, I treat linguistics as a scientifi c activity and explore some instances of dualism. By extracting some ubiquitous aspects of scientifi c methodology from its typically quantitative expression, I show that two recent instances of methodologically dualistic critiques of linguistics are ill-founded. I then show that there are nonetheless some divergences between linguistic and other ordinary scientifi c methods, refl ecting yet a third instance of methodological dualism.
منابع مشابه
YUASA Yasuo’s Theory of the Body A Keynote Speech Delivered at the symposium “Contemporary Japanese Concept of the Body,” held at the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, England, June 5-6, 2006
Key terminologies: 1) Commonsensical dualism (disjunctive dualism), 2) Methodological reflection (prāxis over theōria, 3) Self-cultivation (transformation from disjunctive dualism to correlative dualism, perfection of personality, imageexperience, synchronicity), 4) Body-scheme (four information circuits), 5) Implications (being-in-nature vs. being-outside-of-nature, micro-macrocosmic correlati...
متن کاملA Middle Way Way of Emptying Dualism in Social Theory
A variety of theories in the social science, as profound as they may seem, cannot break away from “either-or” dualism. In which, many of them assume dualistic substantialisms in terms of the dichotomies like: methodological individualism vs. methodological collectivism; positivistic sociology vs. intepretivist sociology; agency vs. structure, and so on. In addition to that, there is also anothe...
متن کاملHedayat’s Neighbour: The Fictional Legacy of Gholam-Hosayn Sa’edi, Ghahreman Shiri, Tehran: Butimar, 2015. pp. 284 .
متن کامل
Dualism of the Soul and the Body in the Philosophical System of Ibn Sīnā and Descartes
The problem of human's two domains has a significant influence on human knowledge, and since the human privilege in the universe to the other beings as well as the immateriality of the soul and so on is based on proving the soul's substance separately, it worths to search in this issue about the ideas of two Western and Islamic philosophers. Ibn Sīnā with arguments such as the "suspending man" ...
متن کاملReform by reflection: Schön’s legacy to management practice in times of uncertainty
In this paper, we revisit Donald Schön’s scholarly work on “handling uncertainty”, suggesting that in order to cope reasonably well with uncertainty, practitioners should be encouraged to take a reflective existential stance, aimed to explore their own tacit personal style (i.e., theories-in-use). They should (i) recall and reflect on their theories-in-use to bear on the phenomenon, (ii) metaph...
متن کامل